Several years back I suggested a type of compensating nozzle that should be inexpensive to build and test. Unfortunately the ones I made for demonstration with compressed air were hit and miss as I didn’t have the theory quite right. Hit and miss is not good enough for serious companies, so I mostly dropped the idea for a while. I thought a few of my acquaintances in the business might do something with the idea for a while. Now I think the idea has been mostly forgotten as unworkable.
A few years back I did finally find the missing part of the concept and did nothing about it as I thought at the time that others had picked it up and moved on. Since I don’t think that has happened, I am going to repost the concept.
On the left is the engine with the notch showing on the right side. The notch allows the atmosphere to enter the bell to compensate for over expansion at lower altitudes. At higher altitudes and in vacuum the exhaust gradually uses the whole bell with some losses through the notch. This will allow a nozzle to be optimum at sea level when most are over expanded. It will also be nearly as good as a full diameter high expansion nozzle in regimes with the exhaust under expanded.
The missing ingredient in the prior concept was appreciation for the momentum of the exhaust at the notch site. The momentum, especially with the rounded notches that I was advocating before, would prevent the atmosphere from entering the notch in a controlled manner. The addition of a sharp edge at the notch to assure a clean break and a slight reverse on the notch edge to direct the exhaust inwards controls the momentum of the exhaust in a manner that allows the atmosphere to interact and provide pc/pa compensation at a range of back pressures.
A compensating nozzle allows lower pressure engines to operate more efficiently in a launch vehicle. They should allow a payload increase of 1-5% depending on the vehicle and the assumptions going in. For a VTVL that wants to operate at very low pressures in the landing phase, a compensating nozzle would be a very important upgrade, though the successes of Blue and SpaceX take some of the edge off that argument.
This is a public domain concept as I described it here years ago. So anyone that wants to see what I am talking about can build a quick and dirty nozzle to use with shop air. The ones have done were an air chuck and fiberglass. About $10.00 in materials. I know it works at 135 psi. Then you can try a higher pressure gas if it might be useful to you or someone you know.
Are stars better appreciated for their art after they die? Actually, stars usually create their most artistic displays as they die. In the case of low-mass stars like our Sun and M2-9 pictured above, the stars transform themselves from normal stars to white dwarfs by casting off their outer gaseous envelopes. The expended gas frequently forms an impressive display called a planetary nebula that fades gradually over thousands of years.
M2-9, a butterfly planetary nebula 2100 light-years away [...]
Lights sprawl toward the horizon in this night skyscape from Uludag National Park, Bursa Province, Turkey, planet Earth. The stars and nebulae of the Milky Way are still visible though, stretching above the lights on the northern summer night while three other planets shine brightly. Jupiter is at the far right, Mars near the center of the frame, and Saturn is just right of the bulging center of our galaxy.
Because the panoramic scene was captured on July 6, all three planets pictured were h [...]
The Expedition 48 crew is beginning work on new science delivered aboard the SpaceX Dragon space freighter. More cargo is also being unloaded from the new Russian Progress 64 resupply ship.
NASA astronaut Kate Rubins has begun work on the new Heart Cells study that will observe how heart muscle tissue adapts to microgravity. Rubins also partnered with Japanese astronaut Takuya Onishi for the Body Measures experiment that researches how the body shape changes in outer space. Onishi later setup [...]
Celebrating its 50th anniversary this year, the TV series "Star Trek" has captured the public’s imagination with the signature phrase, "To boldly go where no one has gone before." NASA's Hubble Space Telescope doesn't "boldly go" deep into space, but it is "boldly peering" deeper into the universe than ever before to explore the warping of space and time and uncover some of the farthest objects ever seen.
When "Star Trek" was first broadcast in 1966, the largest telescopes on Earth could on [...]
NASA's Mars rover Curiosity is now selecting rock targets for its laser spectrometer -- the first time autonomous target selection is available for an instrument of this kind on any robotic planetary mission.
Using software developed at NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Pasadena, California, Curiosity is now frequently choosing multiple targets per week for a laser and a telescopic camera that are parts of the rover's Chemistry and Camera (ChemCam) instrument. Most ChemCam targets are still s [...]
The search for distant solar system objects has found two more small worlds far outside the orbit of Neptune. The new objects are located beyond the Kuiper Belt, which is a belt of small icy objects just beyond Neptune, of which Pluto is a member. They have the third and fourth most-distant perihelia, which is when an object has its closest approach distance to the Sun, of any known solar system objects.
In addition, the orbital motions of these objects are in resonance with Neptune’s orbit [...]
The hatches between Dragon and station were opened at 2:27 p.m. EDT Wednesday, July 20. The crew entered to document the interior and will begin unloading cargo this afternoon.
The spacecraft delivered nearly 5,000 pounds of science, hardware and supplies, including instruments to perform the first-ever DNA sequencing in space, and the first of two identical international docking adapters (IDA). The IDAs will provide a means for commercial spacecraft to dock to the station in the near future [...]
The SpaceX Dragon cargo spacecraft was bolted into place on the Harmony module of the International Space Station at 10:03 a.m. EDT as the station flew about 252 statute miles over the California and Oregon border.
The spacecraft is delivering nearly 5,000 pounds of science, hardware and supplies, including instruments to perform the first-ever DNA sequencing in space, and the first of two identical international docking adapters (IDA). The IDAs will provide a means for commercial spacecraft [...]